This will be an analytical accounting of the big oasis tank; its creation, loss, and what went wrong. I'm writing this as a record, the only one there is, hoping when I'm gone, it'll be documentation.
Back when my dear late husband, Sherwood, and I built it in 1997, we didn't think about how long it would last. If we had, we'd probably have figured something like 30 years. (It made it 28 years.)
 |
Sherwood and me |
We felt the tank would be too big to concrete, so we invested in a very expensive Permalon liner. As we put it down, with family's help, we left it plenty loose, plus the material was very stretchy. Once that was done, I went to work at beautifying the edges. For a month I hauled tons of rocks to anchor and beautify it.
It was exhilerating to watch it fill for the first time, and finally not lose all the precious flash flood runoff. I estimate it holds between 200,000-250,000 gallons.
I wasn't prepared for the problems ahead. First, the weight of the water caused the ground below, and probably the walls even more so, to compact and recede, which wasn't a problem at the time, since the Permalon was stretchy. In this next photo, you can see how taut the sides are stretched with the weight of water. If the Permalon hadn't been stretchy, it would have pulled my rock work into the tank. Of course, in hindsight, I should have left at least a foot of slack in the tank on all sides. There was plenty of material to do so.
Next, deer and javelina got into the tank. Their hoofs poked holes in it. That by itself, couldn't be tolerated. But also, javelina couldn't get out the slippery sides, and drowned. So I patched the holes and fenced the tank.
That didn't work. The fence didn't keep them out, and where it went across the spillway, so much debris accumulated that water couldn't enter the tank. The first surge of a flash flood carries tons of debris in it. Not to mention, a fence ruined the ambience.
The only other option was concrete. We knew we couldn't do it alone, so we hired a crew. They were all set up inside the tank when we discovered that, while the concrete they were pouring was sufficient weight on the liner floor, it wasn't heavy enough to make the liner lay againt the sloped sides. I'm sure the more it stretched, the harder it would be to stretch it further.
Two options, either remove all the rock anchoring/beautification, loosening the liner that way, or cut the liner. It was May, with rain showers happening almost daily. The floor was already mostly done. We didn't know how long it would take to finish the project, but more importantly, when a monsoon would come. We couldn't chance leaving it vulnerable to a monsoon. It took a month to finish the project and almost every night we removed the equipment, just in case. I felt I had no choice but to cut the liner.
Through the years wave action eroded the upper several feet of concrete wall. During construction, I had packed the cement onto a wire framework to hold it as best I could, but it was nearly 10 feet tall and too sloped for a ladder to stay in place, so not the best workmanship. Subsequently, I patched endlessly. One time, the late Bill Lindeman and Jane Crone came and helped with the patching. And it never held. Wave action would soon have it crumbling into the tank.
 |
Bill and me in June 2011 |
Eventually the upper sides eroded beyond repair. Herds of deer and javelina were constantly clamoring up and down the sides, which hurt too. Here is the spillway area mid-December last year.
So now, the unthinkable has happened. I theorize that water coming into the spillway surged under the liner somehow, causing the tank to float and collapse. It's basically a dirt tank now. I expect it to be dry within a month... unless we get another monsoon.
The only thing that could have made the wire-concreted mesh buckle upward like that is the whole tank being pushed up during the deluge. Huge slabs of concrete came loose and tumbled into the tank.
The next photo shows the spillway where the water surged in and shoved the tank wall, such as it was, into the tank in a twisted heap.
Maybe when the tank is empty, someone can figure out a solution, but I'm preparing myself with the expectation of not being able to maintain as many trees as in the past. Also I plan to be more vigilant at patching the smaller "stucco" tank. With that not leaking, plus the new above-ground tank, the oasis might be able to survive almost as well, I think. But a hard lesson re-learned..... nothing is forever!